|
Author |
Thread Statistics | Show CCP posts - 13 post(s) |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 16:35:00 -
[1] - Quote
This is a very bad idea.
You can in effect remove the enemy FC and mastermind from the match before it even begins. Why? Why let someone work so hard for so many months and then tell them, "Well the other team doesnt want you here so you are now not able to fight in the match. Sorry you worked so hard to get here but too bad!"
They only way someone should be removed from the match is forcibly through their ship!
Wild
Please reconsider this rule. Do not take away the tournament from someone who worked so hard to get in. |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 18:06:00 -
[2] - Quote
Please dont forget that you are also banning a PLAYER from the match, and not just the ship.... Like if we were fighting PL, or HYDRA.... I would make banning Shamis, or Garmon a priority over the ship!
Also WTH is with this automatic qualifier to the finals for the final four teams from last year? Does this mean we do not participate in the qualifiers? Does it mean we get #1 seeds in the four regions? And why? why should we get a bye, from last years status? Everyone should have to prove themselves again, including my team which was in the top four last year! |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 18:18:00 -
[3] - Quote
Brinxter wrote:DHB WildCat wrote:Please dont forget that you are also banning a PLAYER from the match, and not just the ship.... Like if we were fighting PL, or HYDRA.... I would make banning Shamis, or Garmon a priority over the ship!
Also WTH is with this automatic qualifier to the finals for the final four teams from last year? Does this mean we do not participate in the qualifiers? Does it mean we get #1 seeds in the four regions? And why? why should we get a bye, from last years status? Everyone should have to prove themselves again, including my team which was in the top four last year! I agree with this aswell, former glory is well and nice, but it shouldnt make you automatically better then the rest, hell, not with such a new and "exciting" as banning :'-( Make it optional, ask the # 1-4 if they want to skip the pre rounds, id bet they dont even want it.
I know I wouldnt want it.... This is the ONLY form of PVP in this game with tactics and even odds. I would consider it a punishment if I could not have the opportunity to kick ass! |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 18:30:00 -
[4] - Quote
CCP Sreegs wrote:Tbone Johnson wrote:CCP Sreegs wrote:There's a lot of good dialogue here and I'd just like to take a second to note that what is helpful is an explanation of "why" you think the idea is bad. "This sucks ur an idiot" really doesn't provide anyone with any perspective other than the fact that you're a bad poster.
Theres already 4 pages explaining why when you posted this. The bad poster is U. 4 pages in a 6 page thread. Math. :edit: also, I'm curious to see variety of opinion just as much as I am to see thoughtfulness in opinion. :edit2: That's a p sweet avatar though
Out of curiosity..... Banning a player for doing nothing wrong!? There has to be something in the eula about this and as such I would raise hell if I was banned from anything in EVE because of "no reason"
http://www.eveonline.com/pnp/banning.asp - EULA on banning a player.
I know that paying for a service only to then be told I cannot use said service even when paid for is a criminal act!? Just saying.... |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 18:42:00 -
[5] - Quote
CCP Zirnitra wrote:DHB WildCat wrote:Also WTH is with this automatic qualifier to the finals for the final four teams from last year? Does this mean we do not participate in the qualifiers? Does it mean we get #1 seeds in the four regions? And why? why should we get a bye, from last years status? Everyone should have to prove themselves again, including my team which was in the top four last year! The 4 teams will get a direct spot in the group stages, they will not go straight to the final single elimination stage. You will still have to prove yourself, both in the group stages as well as in the elimination stage, to get a win.
I can live with that... as long as i'm not barred from all the fights i can get! |
DHB WildCat
Flash Over. WE FORM VOLTRON
14
|
Posted - 2011.04.08 18:57:00 -
[6] - Quote
CCP Sreegs wrote:Mr Rive wrote:CCP Sreegs wrote: :edit: also, I'm curious to see variety of opinion just as much as I am to see thoughtfulness in opinion.
Im sorry, what? If by variety of opinion you mean a tally of people who like it and hate it, i think you already have your answer for that. If by variety of alliances, you already have the top 4 teams braying out against it. What more do you want? I could pull my alt on here and say LOL I LIKE DIS IDEA but i dont think it would make it any better... By variety of opinion I mean seeing what happens when you guys go to bed and more than 3 alliances give feedback.
EULA! |
|
|
|